On the off chance it helps others, or if someone wants to add a note to the password reset emails:
I went to reset my password and the initial email went to my spam folder (yahoo mail). Yahoo spam folder disables any links, and neither link would work when I copy/pasted it into the url directly (firefox), I would get here but to an error page.
But the links worked fine out of the email after I sent them to my inbox using the "Not Spam' option. Maybe it was just me, but it would seem the links don't work without a referer from email, or something like that. I know some of our website links won't work unless the referrer comes from a certain link (another webpage).
Cheers,
snypir