Well, we base our clan reviews on a 5 point system. Starting with a short summary on the clan. That can be a broad variaty of things.
- website layout
- background and banner
- forum, about us section, code of conduct and other sections on the site
- clan philosophy, dogma or stigma
- what the clan does for their members on the count of events, tourneys, medals, ribbons, etc
- activity of the clan, website forum and a general member activity
second point is a positives and negatives. After we conduct a survey or audit, we give a list of the clans positives and negatives
Third point is our awards. There are nine awards that can be achieved. More info on the awards you find here.
Our fourth point is the tips and comments, where we give clans advice on what can be improved.
Fifth point is a final rating, based on the four previous points as i explained above.
You can always check out the Clan Nation website and read some of the review there.
http://www.clannation.org/clanreviews
Hope this answered all your questions.
With Kind Regards.
Ronny Henri
CEO Clan Nation
http://www.clannation.org